India: Rejected in Andhra Pradesh , Microfinance Institutions Move to Other States

Oct 2013
India, October, 01 2013 - The Microfinance Institutions (MFI) in Andhra Pradesh are being driven away by the provisions of the APMFI Act and the developments that followed, according to the industry.

While the largest and only listed MFI has shifted its base to Mumbai, others like Basix, Spandana, Share and Asmitha are spreading to other States in India and abroad.

The MFIs in the State clocked losses of over Rs. 6,500 crore in Andhra Pradesh following the APMFI Act, 2011 which is intended to control high interest rates, coercive collections and illegal insurance practices by the MFIs. Within a year, the operations of the MFIs in the State have come down to less than 10% besides reduction of over 30,000 staff. Companies that bore the brunt include the first listed MFI SKS and others like Share, Basix and Spandana.

“It’s ironic that we are unwanted in Andhra Pradesh but welcomed all the way from Asia Pacific to sub-Saharan Africa. Basix is working with nine countries around the world starting from Papua New Guinea to East Timor on eastern side to Cameroon, Mozambique, Tanzania and Ethiopia in Africa,” said Vijay Mahajan, founder chairman, Basix Microfinance.

“The framework of AP MFI Act is complicated, burdensome and impossible for MFIs to operate. It should be repealed at the earliest,” said Alok Prasad, CEO of Microfinance Institutions Network (MFIN).

After a turn around last quarter, SKS has shifted its head office from Hyderabad to Mumbai a few days ago and is focusing over 90% of its operations in States other than AP. Besides, the company has hired a US based international marketing firm Jack Trout for brand building. “We are back at the threshold of steady growth post our recent turnaround, and require expert counsel in ending the dichotomies/ ambiguities related to branding and positioning,” said S. Dilli Raj, CFO, SKS.

The other players, Spandana, Share and Asmitha too have almost shifted majority of operations to other States. After finding greener pastures elsewhere in India and abroad, the MFIs say that they are portrayed as villains in AP but the whole world wants them.

Repeal Act, State urged

The companies desire that some sense prevails in the State government so that the APMFI Act gets repealed at the earliest.

“After all if the United Nations wants us, World Bank wants us the IFC wants us, the Swiss wants us and the Government of India wants us, so there must be something right with us. We can’t be the villains that the government of AP is trying to paint us as,” Vijay Mahajan said.

However, the silver line for the industry is that the private equity players, who shunned the sector past couple of years, have started showing interest in the MFIs according to the industry analysts.

Source : The Hindu

Research Analysis Tools

The fund indexes, institution benchmarks and other market information displayed here are all Symbiotics designed analysis tools, created in-house by our analysts and experts. Symbiotics has one of the oldest track records in microfinance investment analysis dating back to the late 1990s; its indexes and benchmarks have been regularly used as markers by investors, asset managers, financial institutions and practitioners. These, as well as several other research products, are available through the Research Account. Click on the link below to find out more.

Learn More